A star of the competition, Randall guided the Crows to the inaugural AFLW Premiership and earned All Australian selection in 2017. In 2018, she picked up a string of awards, including the Crows Club Champion and captaincy of the All Australian side. Randall became a three-time All Australian in 2019 as she co-captained the Crows to their second Premiership. She missed the 2020 campaign after tearing her ACL in the first pre-season training and instead took on an assistant coaching role. Randall returned from the injury in 2021 and became sole captain of the side after Erin Phillips stood down.